The Short Answer
Surgery is recommended if your lesion is unstable (loose or partially detached), if you have persistent pain after 12 weeks of conservative care, or if you're an adult with a large lesion (> 2 cm²). Surgical options include arthroscopic drilling, fragment fixation, or osteochondral grafting; costs range from $15,000–$50,000 uninsured [2][8].
Arthroscopic drilling is the simplest surgical option. Your surgeon makes two small cuts (portals) in your knee or elbow, inserts a tiny camera and instruments, and drills small holes into the dead bone. This creates bleeding and triggers your body's healing response. The procedure takes 30–60 minutes, costs $15,000–$25,000, and has a 70–80% success rate for small, stable lesions [8].
Osteochondral autograft transfer (OATS) is used for larger or unstable lesions. Your surgeon removes a small plug of healthy bone and cartilage from a non-weight-bearing area of your joint, then transplants it into the defect. This is more invasive (1–2 hour surgery), costs $20,000–$35,000, but has excellent long-term outcomes (85–90% success) because the graft is your own tissue [2][5].
Osteochondral allograft (donor tissue) is reserved for very large defects (> 2 cm²) or failed autograft. It costs $25,000–$50,000 because the donor tissue must be tested and processed. Recovery is longer (9–15 months), but it's the best option for complex cases. After any surgery, you'll do physical therapy for 12–20 weeks before returning to full sports [2][5][8].